In the Loop - Flying the Competition Roll (2023 Sportsman)

Flying the 2023 Sportsman Sequence - Part 7 – Flying the Competition Roll

by Gordon Penner, IAC 429704, Three-time Master CFI-Aerobatic, FAA Gold Seal CF                  

 

The Competition Aileron Roll 

Competition aileron rolls, which are really slow rolls in technique, are one of the harder things to teach in the basic aerobatic course. You must Not pitch first before initiating the roll as you would in a pure, 1g, Bob Hoover-smooth, coordinated aileron roll (or the zero g Primary roll). A slow roll is definitely not coordinated as top rudder, or sky rudder, is applied in each knife-edge portion of the roll.

Low Horsepower/high drag airplanes struggle with the slow roll unless it is flown at moderate to high airspeeds. Enter the roll as fast as you can.

The main problem in this maneuver is that people do not maintain the straight and level path before, during, and after the roll. Sinking during the roll is quite common, especially in the inverted and second knife-edge portions of the roll. Another problem is not maintaining a constant roll rate. Most pilots allow the roll rate to speed up in the second half of the roll.

People also end up off heading, usually to the right in a left roll. 

The key to a good competition aileron (slow) roll is picking a spot on the horizon, and then drawing Alan Cassidy's scared circle with the tip of the nose around that spot. John Morrissey's "deep focus" must be maintained throughout the roll, which will be a challenge in and of itself as the controls are manipulated.

If we consider a left roll, the tip of the nose starts at 6 o'clock on the sacred circle, rotates counterclockwise up to 3 o'clock for the first knife-edge, continues up to the 12 o'clock when inverted, down to 9 o'clock for the second knife-edge, then back to 6 o'clock. The controls must be manipulated in such a way to "draw" that sacred circle with the tipe of the nose around that point on the horizon.

Remember our earlier conversation from Rich Stowell about pitch and yaw? That will apply here.

Former flight instructor of the year and master CFI-aerobatic Rich Stowell said it best. He stated that the flight controls work in relation to the pilot not the horizon. Pitch is a head-to-foot motion of the tip of the nose of the airplane, not up and down. Yaw is an ear-to-ear motion of the tip of the nose of the airplane, not left and right. Up and down and left and right, in relation to the horizon, only work in upright flight with less than 40 degrees of bank. Up and down and left and right ideas do not work in knife-edge or inverted flight.
Some airplanes need a higher nose attitude when inverted at the 12 o’clock position on the sacred circle. That makes the sacred circle tall at the 12 o’clock point, which is why I sometimes call the sacred circle the “sacred egg.” To find this 12 o’clock attitude, the pilot must first fly inverted at different speeds to see how high the nose has to be above the horizon while holding an altitude.
 
When rolling past 3 o’clock on the sacred circle, on the way to 12 o’clock, there must be enough push added to get the nose up to the correct inverted attitude. Blend this push in between 3 o’clock and 12 o’clock. 

Enough knife-edge practice must be flown to determine how much top rudder must be held to maintain altitude at the selected speeds. Since an aircraft in a slow roll is basically in a slip from before the first knife-edge until past inverted (left aileron for the roll and right rudder for “top” rudder), it is losing energy throughout.
 
A good trick taught to me by Emerson Stewart here in Ohio was to not switch the rudders (when switching to the other top rudder) when passing through 12 o’clock, but to wait until about the 10:30 position.
 
Additionally, as it says in Alan Cassidy's book, Better Aerobatics, a little push with the elevator at about the same time as the feet are switched (10:30) will also keep the nose pointed in the right direction as the rolling motion continues, rounding out the second half of the sacred circle. This push will fix the problem of ending off heading to the right all the time.
 
Once the rudder pedals are switched the roll rate will increase, which is a downgrade. This happens because once the pilot shifts to the left rudder for “top” rudder the aircraft is no longer slipping. Ease off the aileron deflection a bit when the rudder pedals are switched so the roll rate stays the same.
 
Fly Safe!

 



Articles in the "2023 Sportsman Sequence" Series

Flying the 2023 Sportsman Sequence by Gordon Penner, In the Loop January 2023

Flying the Wedge by Gordon Penner, In the Loop February 2023

Flying the Immelman, by Gordon Penner, In the Loop March 2023

Flying the Loopby Gordon Penner, Sport Aerobatics December 2019

Flying the Half Cuban, by Gordon Penner, In the Loop May 2023

Flying the Humpty Bump, by Gordon Penner, In the Loop June 2023

Flying the Competition Roll, by Gordon Penner, In the Loop July 2023

Flying the Hammerhead, by Gordon Penner, In the Loop August 2023

Flying the Spin, by Gordon Penner, In the Loop September 2023

Flying the Aerobatic Turn, by Gordon Penner, In the Loop October 2023

 

Online Resources: 

Introduction to Aresti, by Brian Howard, www.iac.org/aerobatic-figures 

 

More articles on typical Sportsman category figures

Half Cubans, Accurate 45-degree downlines, by Giles Henderson, Sport Aerobatics June 2011, pg. 28

A Roll is a Roll is a Roll...., by Gordon Penner, Sport Aerobatics, August 2008, pg. 16

Aerobatic Trim Part 1, by Gordon Penner, Sport Aerobatics September 2020

Aerobatic Trim Part 2, by Gordon Penner, In the Loop October 2020

 

 



 
NOTICE
I. The comments and suggestions contained in this article are based on the general observations of the author. As such, no endorsement or guarantee of any product mentioned herein is intended. In all case of conflict between manufacturer's instructions and contents herein, the former should be adhered to and followed.
II. The author, IAC & EAA present this material for reference only, and expressly deny any and all liability, express or implied, which may result from the use of the suggestions or statements contained herein by any party. Any such party using the suggestions or statements herein, does so at his own risk and without recourse.
III. As a condition of use of the information contained herein, and in consideration of the furnishing thereof, the reader, for himself and his administrators, executors, heirs and assigns, agrees to forever hold harmless and defined the author, IAC and/or the EAA (including any members, officers, directors, agents or employees thereof) from any and all liability or damage of any nature regardless of cause, to reader or any third person, which may result from the use of said materials